Home Residential PropertyBuy-To-LetLandlords face £104 tax bill for every £100 they make as property squeeze deepens

Landlords face £104 tax bill for every £100 they make as property squeeze deepens

by Seamus Doherty Property Reporter
18th Nov 26 3:52 pm

Landlords with large buy-to-let mortgages face paying more in income tax than they earn from their properties under a new tax regime due to take effect in April 2027, according to analysis highlighting the growing financial pressure on Britain’s private rented sector.

A higher-rate taxpayer making £20,000 a year in rental income after running costs, but paying £15,000 in mortgage interest, would have a real profit of £5,000. Yet their tax bill will rise to £5,200 next April — equivalent to £104 for every £100 of profit.

The mortgage interest payment is roughly what would be charged on a £281,000 interest-only buy-to-let loan at the current average rate of 5.34%, according to Landlord Insurance UK.

The same landlord would have paid £2,000 in tax in 2015-16. This year, the bill has reached £5,000, swallowing the entire profit. The increase to £5,200 in 2027 will leave them paying tax on money that has effectively gone towards servicing their mortgage.

Two policy changes are driving the squeeze. The first is the gradual introduction of Section 24, which since 2020 has prevented landlords who own properties in their own names from deducting mortgage interest from rental income before calculating their tax. Instead, they receive a tax reduction calculated at the basic rate, regardless of their own income tax band.

The second is a rise in property income tax rates announced across the 2025 and 2026 Budgets. From April 2027, rates in England, Wales and Northern Ireland will increase to 24 per cent for basic-rate taxpayers, 44 per cent for higher-rate taxpayers and 49 per cent for additional-rate taxpayers. The mortgage interest tax reduction will rise only to 24 per cent.

As a result, higher-rate landlords will pay more in tax than their actual profit whenever mortgage interest exceeds 73.7 per cent of rental profit before interest. For additional-rate taxpayers, the threshold is even lower, at 67.1 per cent.

The impact varies according to how much landlords borrow. An additional-rate taxpayer with £15,000 in mortgage interest against £20,000 of rental profit already pays £6,000 in tax on a real profit of £5,000. From April 2027, that bill will rise to £6,200 — or £124 for every £100 earned.

A higher-rate landlord paying £10,000 in interest will face a £6,400 tax bill, up from £4,000 in 2015-16, a 60 per cent increase. Even landlords without mortgages will see their bills rise, although less sharply: a higher-rate taxpayer with £20,000 in rental profit will pay £8,800, compared with £8,000 in 2015-16.

The economics of buying new rental properties are also deteriorating. Landlord Insurance UK’s yield analysis found that an investor buying a typical home with a 75 per cent mortgage at 5.34 per cent would make no profit before tax in 284 of 316 council areas across England and Wales.

For leveraged landlords, the new tax rates will therefore widen losses that may already exist. Those who own properties outright or have relatively small mortgages face a different pressure, as the higher tax rates will take a larger share of their rental profits.

HM Revenue & Customs estimates that the two-percentage-point increase announced in the 2026 Budget alone will affect about 2.4mn landlords and raise approximately £455mn a year by 2031-32.

The Office for Budget Responsibility has warned that the Budget’s property measures “collectively risk leading to a steady rise in rents”, raising the prospect that landlords could seek to pass some of the additional costs on to tenants.

The changes form part of a longer period of tax and regulatory pressure. Landlord Insurance UK’s timeline identifies 27 changes affecting landlords since 2015 across income tax, stamp duty, capital gains tax, company taxation, council tax and record-keeping requirements. It says 21 increased tax or paperwork burdens, while four reduced them.

Chris Richards, director of Landlord Insurance UK, said landlords with typical buy-to-let mortgages were already handing their entire profit to HMRC, with some facing tax bills exceeding their earnings from next April.

“For agents, that will be the conversation at every renewal: is it still worth carrying on?” he said.

Nine in 10 landlords are individuals and almost half own just one property, Richards added, leaving smaller-scale investors particularly exposed to the changes.

Leave a Comment

You may also like

CLOSE AD